
Welcome to
Catering
From The Rutherford Cafe

Catering for Any Occasion
From breakfast platters to gourmet sandwich trays, our catering menu brings the same fresh, high-quality ingredients and creative combinations you love to your next gathering. Choose from an array of options including our bagel platter with locally roasted coffee, our popular boxed lunches featuring signature sandwiches, or our premium lunch packages with all the fixings. We'll fuel your office meetings and special events with our variety of fresh-made options that accommodate different dietary preferences.
Click below to submit a request if you know what you'd like, or continue scrolling to explore our options!
Meet the Catering Options

Morning Briefing
Great for that early meeting!
1 Dozen Assorted Bagels, 2 tubs of cream cheese, coffee for 10-15, and all the disposable cups, plates, napkins, knives, creamers, etc. that you'll need to get a morning meeting going. Serves 15. $75
Bagel options:
Plain
Everything
5-Grain
Black Russian
Sesame
Blueberry/Cranberry (rotating seasonally)
Gluten Free and Dairy Free options are available, but will incur additional cost.

Sandwich Minis
If you're looking for something that's good for a grazing-style event, minis are a great way to go. We can even team up with The Greater Gouda for extra-large events to do a full grazing table with sandwich minis included!
Varieties Available:
Turkey & Cheddar
Ham & Swiss
Roast Beef & Gouda
Salami & Provolone
Veggie with Roasted Red Pepper Hummus on the side
Generally, we recommend 1.5-2 minis per person depending on the event. $4.50/sandwich mini
If your event is extra-large and you'd like to do a grazing table with charcuterie, sandwich minis, and other snacks, we are able to team up with The Greater Gouda for that. Head over to their website and contact them to work out the details of the grazing table, and they'll get you taken care of with us too!

Boxed Lunches
Great for lunch meetings, pre-wedding meals, or sports teams! Comes with sandwich, chips, cookie, and all condiments on the side in convenient single-serve boxes.
Gluten Free and Dairy Free options are available, but will incur additional cost.
Minimum 5 for delivery.
Mix and match between these options:
Classics - $14 ea
Green Door Gobble: turkey & cheddar on a pretzel bun with lettuce, tomato, & onion
Ham A Lot: ham & swiss on multigrain bread with lettuce, tomato, & onion
Beefy Boy: roast beef & cheddar on a pretzel bun with lettuce, tomato, & onion. Comes with horseradish sauce on the side.
Chicken Salad Sandwich: our famous chicken salad (has red onion and jalapeno in it, just enough for a little kick) with lettuce and tomato on sourdough bread
Pastrami & Swiss on Rye: the name says it all.
Hearty Hummus: roasted red pepper hummus with lots of fresh veggies (lettuce, tomato, onion, carrot, cucumber, banana peppers) on a garlic herb wrap
Greater Gouda Salad: mixed greens, onion, pecans, feta, and dried cranberries with a champagne dressing on the side.
Mediterranean Salad: mixed greens, roasted red pepper hummus, cucumber, onion, carrots, and banana pepper rings with roasted garlic & parmesan dressing (vegan Italian dressing available on request) on the side.
Specialties - $16 ea
Italian Hero: salami, pepperoni, ham, and provolone on a ciabatta bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, & banana pepper rings. Comes with roasted garlic parmesan dressing on the side
Southern Peach: ham & gouda on sourdough bread with lettuce, tomato, & onion. Comes with hot pepper peach jam on the side.
Raging Beast: roast beef & pepper jack on a pretzel bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, and jalapeno relish. Comes with garlic mayo on the side.
Going Clubbing: ham, turkey, bacon, and cheddar on sourdough bread with lettuce, tomato, and onion. Comes with garlic mayo on the side.
Vegan Hero: avocado, spinach, tomato, onion, carrot, and cucumber on a ciabatta bun. Comes with apple cider maple balsamic dressing on the side.
Smokey Sandusky: lebanon bologna, swiss, lettuce, tomato, onion, and sweet horseradish pickles on a pretzel bun.
Ginger Miso Salad: mixed greens, chicken, onion, pecans, cucumber, carrots, and dried cranberries with a ginger miso dressing on the side.
Bridgewalk Salad: mixed greens, turkey, bacon, avocado, cucumber, tomato, carrot, and blue cheese with apple cider maple balsamic dressing on the side.

Sandwich Trays
We can also do trays of full-sized sandwiches with condiments on the side.
The sandwich options for this are:
Green Door Gobble: turkey, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion on a pretzel bun
Beefy Boy: roast beef, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, onion on a pretzel bun. Comes with horseradish sauce on the side.
Pastrami & Swiss on Rye: the name says it all.
Smokey Sandusky: lebanon bologna, swiss, lettuce, tomato, onion, and sweet horseradish pickles on a pretzel bun.
Chicken Salad Sandwich: Our famous chicken salad (with red onion and a touch of jalapeno, just enough for a little kick) on sourdough bread with lettuce and tomato.
Hearty Hummus: roasted red pepper hummus, lettuce, tomato, onion, banana pepper, cucumber, carrot in a garlic herb wrap.
$9.99 ea
We usually recommend up to 1 full sandwich per person, depending on the type of event and what other food will be available.

Lucy's Luncheon Platter
Got a board meeting or a training coming up? Need something that scales well to accommodate a crowd? This option works great for any group of 15 or more.
15 Assorted Sandwiches, cut in half and arranged on a tray with a bowl of condiments on the side, 1 large Greater Gouda Salad (feta, pecans, onion, dried cranberries, mixed greens) with champagne dressing on the side, 20 individual bags of chips and 20 individually-wrapped cookies, and all the disposable plates, forks, etc. that you'll need.
Choose from these sandwich options for your platter:
Green Door Gobble: turkey & cheddar on a pretzel bun with lettuce, tomato, & onion
Ham A Lot: ham & swiss on multigrain bread with lettuce, tomato, & onion
Beefy Boy: roast beef & cheddar on a pretzel bun with lettuce, tomato, & onion. Comes with horseradish sauce on the side.
Chicken Salad Sandwich: Our famous chicken salad (with red onion and a touch of jalapeno, just enough for a little kick) on sourdough bread with lettuce and tomato.
Hearty Hummus: roasted red pepper hummus with lots of fresh veggies (lettuce, tomato, onion, carrot, cucumber, banana peppers) on a garlic herb wrap
Serves ~15-20. $260
Gluten Free and Dairy Free options are available, but will incur additional cost.

Sides & A La Carte
If you don't need a whole Lucy's Luncheon Platter, but want a little more than just sandwiches, here are some add-ons we can provide for you:
Large Family-sized Greater Gouda Salad: mixed greens, onion, pecans, cranberries, feta, with a bottle of champagne shallot dressing on the side. Serves approximately 20. $42.99
Potato Salad or Pasta Salad: Serves approximately 20. $25
Assorted Individually Bagged Chips: $1.49 ea
Assorted Individually Wrapped Cookies: $2.49 ea regular, $3.49 ea Gluten Free